Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout16247 ORD - 05/13/1981AN ORDINANCE CLOSING THE HEARING OF STREET IMPROVEMENTS FOR THE FOLLOWING STREETS: Washington -Coles Area, Phase IIA 1. "Ramirez Street, from Waco Street to IH 37, 2. Chipito Street, from North Alameda Street to North Staples Street, 3. Waco Street, from West Broadway to Lake Street, 4. Lobo Street, from Sam Rankin Street to North Staples Street, 5. Coke Street, from Uartin Luther Ring Drive to Xaiver Street, 6. Frank Street, from Sam Rankin Street to Nueces Street, 7. Carline Alley, from Frank Street to Lobo Lane, and .8. Lake -Street, from North AlamPda to North Staples Street. AND FINDING AND DETERM•IINING THAT PROPERTY ABUTTING SAID STREETS WILL BE SPECIFICALLY BENEFITED AND ENHANCED IN VALUE IN EXCESS OF COST OF THE ITIPROVEM^ENTS AND LEVYING AN ASSESSMENT, AND FURTHER DELETING BURNS STREET, FROM CHIPITO STREET TO WEST BROADWAY AND RAMIREZ AND CHIPITO STREETS, FROM SAM RANKIN TO BURNS STREET FROM THE PROJECT; AND DECLARING AN E:;ERGENCY. WHEREAS, the City Council of Corpus Christi, Texas, by duly enacted ordinance passed and approved on the 8th day of April. 1981 determined the necessity for, and ordered the improvement of the following streets: 1. Ramirez Street, from Waco Street to IH 37., 2. Chipito Street, from North Alameda Street to North Staples Street, 3. Waco Street, from West Broadway to Lake Street, 4. Lobo Street, from Sam Rankin Street to North Staples Street, _ 5. Coke Street, from Martin Luther King Drive to Xaiver Street, ' 6. Frank Street, from Sam Rankin Street to Nueces Street, • 7. Carline Alley, from Frank Street to Lobo Lane, and 8. Lake Street, from North Alameda to North Staples --- Street. in the manner and according to the plans and specifications heretofore approved and adopted by the City Council by ordinance dated April 8, 1981 a duly executed notice of said ordinance having been filed in the name of the said City with the County Clerk of Nueces County, Texas; and mc,ROFILMED 7 \�89, 16247 WHEREAS, the said City Council has caused the Director of Engineering and Physical Development to prepare and file estimates of the cost of such improvements and estimates of the amount per front foot proposed to be assessed against the property abutting upon a portion of the aforesaid streets within the limits herein defined, to be improved, and the real and true owners thereof, and said Director of Engineering and Physical Development has heretofore filed said estimates and a statement of other matters relating thereto with said City Council, and same has been received, examined and approved by said City Council; and WHEREAS,• said City Council, by duly enacted ordinance dated April 8 1981 , did determine the necessity of levying an assessment for that portion of the cost of constructing said improvements on the above named streets, within the limits herein defined, to be paid by • the abutting property and the real -and true owners thereof, and by ordinance dated April 8 , 1981 , did order and set a hearing to be held at 3:0OP.M. on the 6th day of May , 1981 , at City Hall, in the Council Chambers , in the City of Corpus Christi, Texas, for the real and true owners of the property abutting upon said streets, within the limits above defined, and for all other owning or claiming any interest in, or otherwise interested in said property, or any of said matters as to the assessments and amounts to be assessed against each parcel of abutting property and the real and true owner or owners thereof, and as to the special benefits to accrue to said abutting property by virtue of said improvements, if any, or concerning any error. invalidity, irregularity or deficiency in any proceedings, or contract, to appear and be heard in person or by counsel and offer evidence in reference to said matters; and the City - Council did by said ordinance order and direct the City to give notice of said hearing to the owners abutting upon said streets as shown by the current ad valorem tax roll by mailing such notice to such owners and publishing said notice at least three times in the Corpus Christi Times before the date of the hearing, such notice of mail and by publication being in compliance with the provisions of Article 1105b of Vernon's Annotated Civil Statutes of Texas; and -2- WHEREAS, such notice was given said owners of property as shown on the current ad valorem tax roll within the limits of the streets being improved by mailing such notice at least fourteen (14) days prior to the hear- ing to such owners and by publishing three times notice of such hearing in the Corpus Christi Times, the first of which publication was at least twenty-one (21) days prior to the date of said hearing; both forms of notice being in com- pliance with and containing the information required by Article 1105b, Vernon's Annotated Civil Statutes; and WHEREAS, after due, regular and proper notice thereof, all as provided • by law and the Charter of the City of Corpus Christi, said hearing of which notice was given,' was opened and held on May 6 , 1981 , in the Council Chambers, City Hall , in the City of Corpus Christi, Texas, in accordance with said ordinance and notice, at which time an oppor- tunity was given to all said abovementioned persons, firms, corporations and estates, their agents and attorneys, to be heard and to offer evidence as to all matters in accordance with said ordinance and notice, at which time the following appeared and offered the following testimony: -3- There being no further testimony offered or any further parties appearing to be heard, upon proper motion, duly seconded and unanimously carried, the said hearing was declared closed; and WHEREAS, no further parties appearing and no further testimony being offered as to the special benefits in relation to the enhanced value of said abutting property as compared to cost of the improvements of said portion of said streets proposed to be assessed against said property, or as to any errors, invalidities or irregularities, in the proceeding or contract hereto- fore had in reference to the portions of said streets to be improved; and WHEREAS, said City Council has heard evidence as to the speical benefits and enhanced value to accrue to said abutting property, and the real and true owner or owners thereof, as compared with the cost of making said imporvements on said streets within the limits above defined, and has heard all parties appearing and offering testimony, together with all protests and ob- jections relative to such matters and as'to any errors, invalidities or irregularities in any of the proceedings and contract for said improvements, and has given a full and fair hearing to all parties making or desiring to make - any such protest, objection or offer testimony and has fully examined and con- sidered all evidence, matters, objections and protests offered and based upon said evidence, testimony and statements, said City Council finds that each and every parcel of property abutting upon the portion of the streets aforesaid within the limits to be improved as herein defined, will be enhanced in value and specially benefited by the construction of said improvements upon the said streets upon which said property abuts, in an amount in excess of the amount of the cost of said improvements proposed to be, and as hereinbelow assessed against each and every said parcel of abutting property, and the real and true owners thereof, and said City Council did consider and correct all error, invali- dities or deficiences called to its attention and did find that all proceedings and contracts were proper and in accordance with the Charter of said City and the laws of the State of Texas, under which those porceedings were being had, and the proceedings of said City Council heretofore had with reference to such improvements, and in all respects to be valid and regular; and said City Council did further find upon said evidence that the assessments hereinbelow made and the charges hereby declared against said abutting property on the portions of -4- the streets hereinabove described, within the limits defined, and the real and true owner or owners thereof, are just and equitable and did adopt the rule of apportionment set out below and the division of the cost of said improvements between said abutting properties, and the real and true owner or owners there- of, as just and equitable, and as producing substantial equality considering the benefits to be received and the burdens imposed thereby, and that all ob- jections and protests should be overruled and denied except the corrections and charges as appear on the final assessment roll included in this ordinance. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CORPUS CHRISTI, TEXAS: SECTION 1. That there being no further protest or testimony for or against said improvements, said hearing granted to the real and true owners of abutting property on said streets, within the limits above defined, and to all persons, firms, corporations and estates, owning or claiming same or any inter- est therein, be and the same is hereby closed and all protests and objections, whether specifically mentioned or not, shall be, and the same are hereby over- ruled and denied. SECTION 2. That said City Council hereby finds and determines upon the evidence heard in reference to each and every parcel or property abutting upon the aforesaid streets, within the limits defined, that the special ben- efits in the enchanced value to accrue to said property and the real and true owner of owners thereof, bu virture to the construction of said improvements to said portion of said streets upon which said property abuts, will be in excess of the amount of the cost of said improvements as proposed to be, and as herein assessed against said abutting property and the real and true owners thereof, and finds that the apportionment of the cost of said improvements, and that all assessments hereinbelow made are just and equitable and produce substantial equality considering the befefits received and the burdens imposed thereby, and are in accordance wiht the laws of the State of Texas, and the Charter pro- visions of the City of Corpus Christi, Texas, and that the proceedings and contract heretofore had with reference to said improvements are in all respects regular, proper and valid, and that all prerequisites to the fixing of the assessments liens against said abutting properties, as hereinabove described and -5- ti the personal liability of the real and true owner or owners thereof, whether named or correctly named herein or not, have been in all things regularly had and performed in compliance with the law, Charter provisions and proceedings of the said City Council. SECTION 3. That in pursuance of said ordinance, duly enacted by said City Council, authorizing and ordering the improvements of the above described street, within the limits defined, and in pursuance of said pro- ceedings heretofore had and enacted by said City Council, in reference to said improvements and by virtue of the powers vested in said City with respect to said street improvements by the laws of the State of Texas and the Charter 106 of the Acts of the First Called Session of the 40th Legilature of the State of Texas, known and shown as Article 1105b of Vernon's Annotated Civil Statutes of Texas, as amended, there shall be, and is hereby levied, assessed and taxed against the respective parcels or property abutting upon said por- tion of said streets, and against the real and true owners thereof, whether such real and true owner or owners be named or correctly named herein or not, the several sums of money hereinbelow mentioned and itemized opposit the description of the respective parcels of said property, the number -of -front feet of each and the several amounts assessed against same and the real and true owner or owners thereof, and names of the apparent owners thereof, all as corrected and adjusted by said City Council, being as follows, to -wit: -6- PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL WASHINGTON-COLES, PHASE IIA STREET IMPROVEMENTS MAY 13, 1981 This project includes improvements to the following streets: 1. Ramirez Street, from Waco Street to IH 37, 2. Chipito Street, from North Alameda Street to North Staples Street, - 3. Waco Street, from West Broadway to Lake Street, 4. Lobo Street, from Sam Rankin Street to North Staples Street, 5. Coke Street, from Martin Luther King Drive to Xaiver Street, 6. Frank Street, from Sam Rankin Street to Nueces Street, 7. .Carline Alley, from Frank Street to Lobo Lane, and 8. Lake Street, from North Alameda to North Staples Street. These sheets shall be constructed by excavation to a width and depth to permit the laying of a standard curb and gutter section, 6" compacted subgrade, 8" compacted "calicha-base and 11/2" Type "D" Hot Asphaltic pavement. Streets will vary from 24' to 33.9' in width and shall be constructed within the existing right-of-way. There will be 4' or 5' wide reinforced concrete sidewalks 4" thick and 6" thick reinforced concrete driveways as shown on the plans or where requested by the owners. The assessment rates have been calculated in accordance with the latest paving policy of the -City. Based on this policy and the low bid submitted by Heldenfels Brothers, the assessment rates are as follows: 24' WIDE STREET, BOC 4" Curb, Gutter & Pavement Modified Curb, Gutter & Pavement 28' WIDE STREET, BOC 4" Curb, Gutter & Pavement 6" Curb, Gutter & Pavement 1 311 WIDE STREET, BOC . 4" Curb, Gutter & Pavement 6" Curb, Gutter & Pavement 33.9' SIDE STREET, BOC 4" Curb, Gutter & Pavement Sidewalks Driveways RESIDENTIAL, SCHOOL AND CHURCHES 4" or .6" Curb, Gutter & Pavement Sidewalks Driveways TOTAL CONTRACT PRICE PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENTS TOTAL CITY PORTION JKL/dl -BID PRICE $10.10 $12.58 $13.02 $13.62 $15.46 $16.06 $17.71 $ 1.90 $ 3.25 $277,930.90 60,765.77 $217,165.13 ASSESSMENT RATE $10.41 L.F. $13.171.F. $13.45 L,F. $14.10 L.F. $15.74 L.F. $16.39 L.F. $17.94 L.E. $ 1.00 S.F. $ 3.51 S.F. $ 4.75 L.F. $ .75 S.F. $ 3.51 S.F. tl^�/ James K. Lantos, '.E. Assistant City Manager 1.70UATA UULUWt TS/ NL L MAY 13, 19R1 PAGE 1 1 =ITEM = NO. OWNER AND PROPFRTV DFSCRTPTTDN DESCRIPTION QUANTITY OF ASSFSSFn ASSFSSMFNT RATF AMaIINT .l TOTAL 2 AMOUNT B ACSFCSFR d e s 6 ] . ' B B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL WASHINGTON COLES TI,PHASE A ft nSfCIG 1 -IF APT HO BO 1= ° 12 RAMIRF7 STREFT u 1. 16 1' 16 6 WACO ST. TO I.H. 37 NORTH SIDE ;; 20 6 " 1 "F CITY OF CORPUS nlD RAYVTFW CFMFTFRY 359.50 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. —0— I F.J.G.F. PVMT_ —0— —n— —0— —n— n ., 14 .0 HC 1,398.00 S.F. S/W —0— S.F. S/W 133_45 S_F WU 1—lnr —0— —0— —n— —0— —0— —0— a .B =s . 22 m —0— S.F. 0/W —0— —0— p .00 .1 32 2S S6 .7 I.H. 37 FRONTAGE RD. END RAMIREZ ST_ O. .e .. •• . 26 60 NORTH SIDE 37 . 0 61 •= _ RAMIREZ STREET WACO ST. TO I.H. 37 SOUTH SI OF 01 23 24 " ee . 7 Cf1RPuIS CHRTSTT SCHf1IlI DIST ** 791 nn L F_r_G_f. PVMT_ 4.75 1,39L 75 de a] 80 ='B '°S-27 >➢ COLES ELEMENTRY SCHOOL 801 LEOPARD 78401 LOTS 1 THPU 6 RI k 711 * 270.00 L.F.C.G.E PVMT. 1,200.00 S.F. S/W * 992-00 S -F S/W_ 2.38 .75 38 642.60 900.00 376 96 20 „ .2 w ll d= BLUFF PORTION *SIDE ON WACO ST. ** CR 7 I.F. RTN TH 17 * 150.30 S.F. D/W 1-24 —0— S.F. D/W 3.51 —0— 527.55 —0— " 'e .B as "3,838.86 6' - ° 86 I.H. 37 FRONTAGE ROAD END RAMIREZ ST. SnUTH SIDE . . 89 6B 60 .. 63 se 66 70 ]1 n Bs ]I 79 L & ATA WC➢IENTS/INC MAY 13. 1981 PAGE 9 -< } =ITEM 3 NO. OWNER AND PROPERTY DESCRIPTION DESCRIPTION QUANTITY OF ASSESSET1 ASSESSMENT RATE AMOUNT TOTAL AMOUNT 3 ASSESSED 3 > CHIPITO STREET B N ALAMEDA TO N STAPLES B NORTH SIDE 12 0 13 16 15 '= 3 MRS HANNA BRASLAU * -0- I.F.C.G.E PVMT. -0- -0- '• ,3 508 BUTTERWORTH -0- L.F.C.G.E PVMT. -0- -0- > ,3 NORFOLK VA 23505 -0- S.F. S/W -0- -0- .. ! LOT 14 BLK D -0- S.F. S/W -0- -0- E° . NORTH BROADWAY ADDN -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0- ' '> *CR EXST INPUTS -0- S.F. 0/W -0- -0- 25 . A-1 6 RNTL UNITS E3 19 .00 23 2B 2, 2, EB z. 4 OWEN JACKSON * 127.00 L.F.C.G.E PVMT. 13.17 1,672.59 =23 23 916 WACO 78401 -0- L.F.C.G.E PVMT. -0- -0- 59 33 LOT 15 BLK D ** -0- S.F. S/W -0- -0- 32 25 NORTH BROADWAY ADDN -0- S.F. S/W -0- -0- 33 =6 *CR EXST 13 L.F. CIG -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0- x 3B 27 **CR EXST S/W -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0- » . B-5, COTTON CLUB 33 2. 1,672.59 .. 3. 3. 3Y 42 32 NORTH STAPLES STREET 33 33 FNO CHTPTTO ST. >< NORTH SIDE 33 . 47 76 b . CHIPITO STREET . 3B N ALAMEDA TO N STAPLES 3. 3. SOUTH STOF -2 54 .. 5 A.L. KING * 82.40 L.F.C.G.E PVMT. 6.?5 515.00 33 .. 33 1425 CHIPITO 78401 -0- L.F.C.G.S PVMT. -0- -0- 37 . LOT 8 BLK 52 ** -0- S.F. S/W -0- -0- 3B 33 RI 11FF PORTION -0- S.F. S/W -0- -0- 33 .. E° A-1. DRIVEINN PARKING 303.45 S.F. D/W 1-30C 3.51 1.065.11 .E 3> *CR 4 L.F. RTN N ALAMEDA -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0 - 63 . **NO S/W 33 REDUCED BY COUNCIL 1,580.11 3. 67 5 69 33 ]. 63 72 !9 73 3! 73 7! 2' 79 1 DATA DOCU4ENT5/I11L MAY 1R, 19R1 RAGE___.3 TOTAL AMOUNT ASSFCSFn =ITEM = Nn OWNER AND PRnPFRTY nFSCRIPTInN DESCRIPTION QUANTITY OF ASSFSSFn ASSFSSMFNT RATF AMTIIINT s > 6 ° HAZEL KING 1425 CHIPITO 78401 t nT 9 RI K 52 ** 71.03 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. -0- L.F.C.G.& PVMT. -n- S. F. 5/w 8.85 -0- -n- 628.62 -0- -n- ++ ° ,= BLUFF PORTION *NO S/W A-1, nRTVF TNN * -0- S.F. S/W -0- S.F. D/W -n- S_¢_ n/w -0- -0- -n- -0- -0- -n- , , ,° ,a **REDUCED BY COUNCIL 628.62 ,4 t0 le + 7 ° PEDRO PEREZ GALAN 17n5 S ST.. I * ** 109.12 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. -,- • MT- -0- S.F. S/W -0- S.F. S/W A2_74 C.F. n/W 1-1n 6.71 -n- -0- -0- 1.51 732.20 -n- -0- -0- 770_27 => :. 6. _> >a , _' _+ LOTS 263 & 4 BLK 52 BLUFF PORTION R-5, 1 RFC UNIT __ *CR 74.621 EXST IMPVTS. **NO S/W R Fnllf Fn RV CnIJNC II -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0- b a, 952..424 =a _> NnRTH STAP1 FS STREFT 23 14 1, 2° =. P °41 END CHIPITO ST. SOUTH SIDE " >s °D as w WACO STREET RRnenwev in IAKF ST. ax .> °a SOUTH SIDE as r 8 " ° CITY OF CORPUS OLD BAYVIEW CEMETERY Hr 360.00 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. -0- L.F.C.G.& PVMT. 1,44n_n0 S -F- S/W -0- -0- -0- -0- -0- -0- >o s, as a: -0- S.F. 5/W -0- S.F. 0/W -n- C _ n/w -0- -0- -0- -0- -0- -0- °' s° as .00" sa sa as U 66 as °' u RAMIREZ STREET : 8A CORPUS INDEPENDENT SCHOOL " S DISTRICT , B-13 801 LFnPean 7R4n1 270.00 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. -0- L.F.C.G.& PVMT. 992-00 S.F- S/W -0- -0- -n- -0- -0- -n- °> u '= '° 's °' 1s COLES ELEMENTRY SCHOOL LOT 6 & 7 BLK 71 : LUPE PORTION -0- S.F. S/W 150.30 S.F. D/W 1-24 -I- I -0- -0- -I- -0- -0- -I- °' SEE ITEM 8-13. >. .00 n IV BATA OOLNmENTS/INC } MAY 11, 1981 DESCRIPTION QUANTITY OF ASSESSED ASSESSMENT RATE PAr•F 4 AMOUNT TOTAL AMOUNT ASSESSED = ITEM . ND. OWNER AND PROPERTY DESCRIPTION ] 9 CORPUS INDEPENDENT SCHOOL 330.00 L.F.C.G.0 PVMT. 4.75 1,567.50 ° ° S DISTRICT -0- L.F.C.G.E PVMT. -0- -0- . 801 LEOPARD 78401 * -0- S.F. S/W -0- -0- _ ° ALL BLK 72 -0- S.F. S/W -0- -0- BLUFF PORTION -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0- _ *CR FXST S/W -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0- ] COLES ELEMENTRY " ° 1,567.50. ! t. LAKE/WINNEBAGO STREETS u 18 END WACO ST. . ° SOUTH SIDE _' _' !. WACO STREET =' _' W. BROADWAY TO WINNEBAGO ST ;, _. NORTH SIDE u :. x ]] = 10 H. MOSIFN E CO. INC. 150.00 I.F.C_(.E PVMT. 14.10 9,115 DD » BOX 2132 -0- L.F.C.G.0 PVMT. .00 -0- ]T m DALLAS TX 75221 600.00 S.F. S/W 1.00 600.00 m ]• I ❑T1 RI K 6q -0- S.F. S/W -0- -0- - '0 _. BLUFF PORTION -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0- ]= VACANT -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0- ,, 2471 5.00 *' .. 11 MAX DRSHANSKI FS , , of • „ 1 49 b . C/O ABE BLOCK -0- L.F.C.G.0 PVMT. -0- -0- o BOX 882 78403 600.00 S.F. S/W 1.00 600.00 „ m IOT 10 RLK 69. -0- S F. S/W -0- -0- , _' BLUFF PORTION 73.30 S.F. D/W 1-10 3.51 257.28 " ° I-2 -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0- 3' 1 RFS UNIT u '! 2,972.28" u 58 ], C] 60 8° RAMIREZ STREET 61 62 " °! m _' 12 ST. MATHEWS MISSIONARY 240.00 L.F.C.G.0 PVMT. 4.75 1,140.00 89 so BAPTIST CHURCH -0- L.F.C.G.0 PVMT. .00 -0- ;; ' 1119 WACO 78401 * -0- S F S/W .00 -0- '= LOTS 1,2 & 12 BLK 68 -0- S.F. S/W .00 -0- ° ]] BLUFF PORTION 120.45 S.F. D/W 1-12 3.51 422.78 � . *CR FXST. S/W 143.45 S.F. D/W 1-13C 3.51 503.51 .x 9 2,066.29 ,6 „ I' )5 31 uninuuLW t) IsnML MAY13, 1921 PAGE 5 , 2 ITEM OWNER AND DESCRIPTION QUANTITY OF TDTAL AMOUNT 2 NO. PROPERTY..DESCRIPTION ASSESSED ASSESSMENT RATE AMOUNT ASSESSED • 8 S 7 2 CHIPITO STREET . 11 p ,2 • 13 SOLEDAD PEREZ GALAN 150.00 L.F.C.G.E PVMT. 15.74 2,361.00 i, 1205.N STAPLES 78401 —0— L.F.C.G.E PVMT. —0— —0- 12 LOT J BLK 67 ' * —0— S.F. S/W — — —0— 16 BLUFF PORTION —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— 17 A-1 —0— S. F. D/W —0— —0— ,e +• *CR EXST S/W —0— S.F 0/W —0— —0— 20 • 6 RNTL UNITS 2t + 2,361.00 „ 2. 2• 14 HENRY W. REED 150.00 L.F.C.G.E PVMT. 15.74 2,361.00 27 2+ 349 PHIL ELENA ST. —0— L.F.C.G.E PVMT. —0— —0— 29 22 PHILADELPHIA PA.19119 * —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— 29 2• LOT 12 BLK 67 —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0- ,, 1, BLUFF PORTION —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— 2t 2. A-1 —0— S.F. D/W —0— _ —0— 3. 2• *CR EXST S/W >a 2 1 RES UNIT 2,361.00". 2.. 29 n 2. . 2. - I AKF STREET °0 2, END WACO ST. 22 NORTH SIDE p 2f a e 2' LOBO STREET ., •• SAM RANKIN ST. TO N STAPLES 19 n m ti -. NORTH SIDE 4. .S 2= 15 ST. PAUL METHODIST CHURCH 150.00 L.F.C.G.E PVMT. 4.75 712.50 32 •+ C/0 REV. E.J. TANNER —0— L.F.C.G.E PVMT. .00 —0- 92 1202 SAM RANKIN 78401 520.00 S.F. S/W .75 390.00 55 u LOT 12 BLK 54 —0— S.F. S/W .00 —0 — 67 . BLUFF PORTION 328.45 S.F. 0/W 1-20C 3.51 1,152.86 ;; 0 —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— a< 24 2,255.36 7 89 a. a. 16 MAX ORSHANSKI ESTATE * 143.00 L.F.C.G.E PVMT. 13.45 1,923.35 45 .. C/O ABE BLOCK —0— L.F.C.G.G PVMT. —0— —0— 97 •+ BOX 882 78403 600 00 S F S/W 1 00 600 00 a 2 LOT 1 BLK 54 —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— 9' • BLUFF PORTION —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— 73 e< A-1 —0— S F n/,—n— - —n— a 55 *CR 7 L.F. RTN ALAMEDA Jt ;; 5 RNTL UNITS 2,523.35. "2' 7 MAY i3, 1981 PAGE 6 : ITEM 3 NO. OWNER AND PROPERTY DESCRIPTION DESCRIPTION QUANTITY OF ASSESSED ASSESSMENT RATE AMOUNT TOTALil AMOUNT ; ASSESSED . ' ALAMEDA STREET . „ . 17 AURORA CANTU * 291.00 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. 13.45 3,913.95 '� „ 3013 AGNES 78405 —0— L.F.C.G.& PVMT. —0— ,: LOTS 12 & 1 BLK 52 1,200.00 S.F. S/W 1.00 1,200.00 a• „ BLUFF PORTION —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— " ,. ,C A -1/B-5 —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— t s *CR 9 L.F. RTN ALAMEDA —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— 2. ,. VACANT - „ 5;113.95; iB '� ,. v • .9 N STAPLES STREET ;; :, END LOBO ST. '. u NORTH SIDE .9 p 31 L a 25 LOBO STREET " 36 SAM RANKIN ST. TO N STAPLES ;, 1' SOUTH SIDE `o A 29 29 29 3. 18 CORPUS INDEPENDENT SCHOOL * 293.00 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. 2.38 697.34 .. ., S DISTRICT —0— L.F.C.G.E PVMT. .00 —0— " 801 LEOPARD 78401 1,004.00 S.F. S/W .38 381.52 2 442 WASHINGTON ELEMENTARY —0— S.F. S/W .00 —0— .. .. BLK 55 BLUFF PORTION 483.45 S.F. D/W 1-30C 3.51 1,696.91 . *CR 7L.F. RTN ALAMEDA ** 195.22 S.F. D/W 1-12C 3.51 685.22 . **CR 1 RADIUS „ 3,460.99 . m s, ,: a ALAMEDA STREET „ 41 4 39 42 M v 19 HOLY CROSS CATHOLIC CHURCH * 295.00 L.F.C.G.E, PVMT. 2.38 702.10 . S REV. NOEL DAVIS —0— L.F.C.G.E PVMT. .00 —0— ;; s 1109 N STAPLES 78401 1,200.00 S.F. S/W .38 456.00 .. .. LOTS 7 & 6 BLK 51 —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— ., BLUFF PORTION —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— ,1 ., 2 STORY UNIT —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— .. w *CR 5 L.F. RTN ALAMEDA ° ° 1,158.101 3 73 9 '. ee 5 7 3 }, MAY 13. 1981 PAGE 7 = ITEM a NO. OWNER AND PROPERTY DESCRIPTION DESCRIPTION QUANTITY OF ASSESSED ASSESSMENT RATE AMOUNT TJTAL AMOUNT , ASSESSED ' 6 a NORTH STAPLES STREET o . END LOBO ST. 9 SOUTH SIDE 1= 10 . 1a 14 13 1= COKE STREET 16 13 MARTIN LUTHER KING TO XAVIER ST. 1a 0 WEST SIDE ,. ,6.. 21 16 1 20 MRS. W.E. LAWRENCE 82.21 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. 13.45 1,105.72 �; ,6 1902 M9RTIN LUTHER DR.78401 —0— L.F.C.G.& PVMT. '.00 —0— _• 1. LOT 4 BLK 3 331.24 S.F. S/W 1.00 331.24 m CRAVEN HEIGHTS ADDN —0— S.F. S/W .00 —0— n =1B-1 83.45 S.F. D/W 1-10 3.51 792.91 za = —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— S9 23 ,o 1,729.87. a 32 =S 33 21 DUDLEY JONES ESTATE * 140.47 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. 13.45 1,889.32 _o C/O C.C. BANK & TRUST —0— L.F.C.G.& PVMT. .00 —0— a. BOX 4666 78408 429.88 S.F. S/W 1.00 429.88 " . LOTS 5A & 6A.BLK 3 —0— S.F. S/W .00 —0— b a CRAVEN HEIGHTS ADDN 135.45 S.F, D/W 1-18 3.51 475.43 '9 a, a= B-1 *INC 15' RTN XAVIER —0— S.F. 0 / W —0— —0— 61 43 as . 794. Al .6 a. •7 u Y a6 XAVTFR STRFFT w .7 END COKE ST. . WEST SIDE S, 3o t.> S= 6< 63 COKE STREET . MARTIN LUTHER KING QR.TO XAVIER 6. '= EAST SIDE 6' S6 0 W .a 22 JOSE MARTINEZ * —0— L.F.C.G.& PVMT. —0— —0— 61 . 812 WEST POINT RD. 78416 —0— L.F.C.G.& PVMT. —0— —0— . .. LOT 1 BLK 2 —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0- 69 CRAVEN HEIGHTS ADDN —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— 66 *CR EXST IMPVTS —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— . 61 —0— S.F. 0/W —0— —0— 66 _ .00' ss ,a >6 E5B 1 7, 2 I 3 $ I 0 A-1, 5 RNTL UNITS 73.30 S.F. D/W 1-10 3.51 73.30 S.F. D/W 1-10 3.51 257.28 257.28 R.11 f1_RA MAY 13, 1981 PAGE 8 S ITEM 3 NO. OWNER AND PROPERTY DESCRIPTION DESCRIPTION QUANTITY OF ASSESSED ASSESSMENT RATE AMOUNT TOTAL ' AMOUNT 3 ASSESSED • 3 3 ' 23 CITY OF CORPUS * -0- L.F.C.G.& PVMT. -0- -0- o . LOT 7 E 8 BLK 2 -0- L.F.C.G.& PVMT. -0- -0- „ , CRAVEN HEIGHTS ADDN -0- S.F. S/W -0- -0- +3 . *NO IMPVTS -0- S.F. S/W -0- -0- II -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0 - 14 13 : -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0- +• 3 000" 4 t0 S 3D . XAVIER STREET 3i END COKE ST. ! EAST SIDE 33 . 20 D ?A :, FRANK STREET 27 :. m SAM RANKIN TO CARLINE ALLEY =' 33 SOUTH SIDE „ u 33 P3 t5 • 24 HENRY GARZA 141.00 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. 13.45 1,896.45 .. > 533 INDIANA 78404 -0- L.F.C.G.S PVMT. .00 -0- �. >e LOTS D & E 564.00 S.F. S/W 1.00 564.00 37 . SALT LAKE SUBD -0- S.F. S/W -0- -0- m . A-1 -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0- b 3, -0- S.F. 0/W -0- -0- °1 3: 2/460.45. b3. 33 25 EDGAR PARRAMORE 23.00 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. 13.45 309.35 n 3. 1307 PEABODY 78407 -0- L.F.C.G.& PVMT. .00 �0- a 37 LOT F 93.00 S.F. S/W 1.00 93.00 S' 35 SALT LAKE SUBD -0- S.F. S/W -0- -0- 31 a A-1 -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0- Si .D -0- S.F. D/W -0- -0- 31 ., 402.35 !9 .E/ 3. .] ,3T .. CARLINE ALLEY 3 END FRANK ST. SO ,. SOUTH SIDE e: 3 .3 .. 66 .3 FRANK STREET 63 . SAM RANKIN ST. TO NUECES ST. s 3, NORTH SIDE se 3 70 3 )3 !. 26 MRS FRANK SPARKS 270.00 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. 13.45 3,631.50 33 33 B 205 ROSEBUD 78404 -0- L.F.C.G.& PVMT. .00 -0- 73 2.639 AC & W 37'LOT 2 BLK 4A 964.52 S.F. S/W 1.00 964.52 74 SALT LAKE SUBD -0- S.F. S/W .00 -0- '9 A-1, 5 RNTL UNITS 73.30 S.F. D/W 1-10 3.51 73.30 S.F. D/W 1-10 3.51 257.28 257.28 R.11 f1_RA ( DATA 00CULDENT5IINC MAY 13+ 1981 PAGE 9 t = ITEM OWNER AND = NO. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION DESCRIPTION QUANTITY OF ASSESSED ASSESSMENT RATE AMOUNT TOTAL AMOUNT ASSESSED 5 > 3 NUECES STREET . io ° SAM RANKIN TO NUECES ST.II ° END NORTH SIDE tx 14 31 35 12 CARLINE ALLEY is I= FRANK ST. TO LOBO LANE " 1. EAST SIDE 3. 30 27 EDGAR PARRAMORE * 75.00 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. —0— —0— 23 . S 1307 PEABODY 78407 —0— I,.F.C.G.E PVMT. —0— —0— 34 10 LOT F —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— �. =a SALT LAKE SUBD —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— n _ *CR EXST INPUTS —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— :a .. —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— 20 =3 A-1 GROCERY STORE 35 • .00 32 = 33 z. r 3s _. 28 ROOSEVELT DUNCAN FLOYD * 31.00 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. —0— —0— ..+ n 1217 SAM RANKIN 78401 —0— L.F.C.G.& PVMT. —0— —0— 3' n N .50 LOT H —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0- 3a BRASLAU SUBD —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— .. 33 A-1 —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— u 3= *CR EXIST INPUT —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— .3 33 1 RES UNIT 69 m .00 7. 33 0 3. /'° .3 29 MAMIE L. DUNCAN * 76.00 L:F.C.G.& PVMT. —0— —0— so . 3710 CRESTWAY DR. —0— L.F.C.G.& PVMT. —0— —0— S3 . I OS AWES CA. 90043 -0- S.F. S/W —0— — — 5= S .50 LOT H & LOT J —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— b3 BRASLAU SUBD —0— S. F. D/W —0— —0— 54 A-1 —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— as " *CR EXST INPUTS 3' U •00 59S. OS .. . • d363 .330 LEATHERS HOUSING PROJECT * —0— L.F.C.G.& PVMT. —0— —0— .. SOUTH SIDE CARLINE ALLEY —0— L.F.C.G.& PVMT. —0— —0— .. .3 *CR EXST IMPUTS —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— 63 3. —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— as .3 —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— w 5= —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— 80 33 .00 ; S. 7l 53 73 36 74 7S t' 39 iy)DATA UU U tNTS/INL MAY 13, 1981 PAGE 10 DESCRIPTION TOTAL = ITEM OWNER AND QUANTITY OF AMOUNT 7 6 NO. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION ASSESSED ASSESSMENT RATE AMOUNT ASSESSED . 6 3 7 6 END CARLINE ALLEY . o • SOUTH SIDE LAKE STREET 6 = N ALAMEDA ST TO N STAPLES . 3 NORTH SIDE 7 6 o . 31 CORNELIA CARSON * 146.00 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. 17.94 2,619.24 11 1224 LAKE 78401 —0— L.F.C.G.& PVMT. .00 —0— 6 LOT 12 BLK 51 480.00 S.F. S/W 1.00 480.00 =. • BLUFF PORTION —0— S.F. S/W .00 —0— __ . A-1 A-1 514.35 S.F. D/W 3-10C 3.51 1,805.37 ;r + *CR 4 LF RTN —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— :. n 5 RNTL UNITS =6 =3 X=15.8 4,904.61m, L n zs 32 HOLY CROSS CATHOLIC CHURCH * 143.00 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. 2.38 340.34 34 =7S REV. NOEL DAVIS —0— L. F. C.G.& PVMT. .00 —0— 3. a 1109 N STAPLES 78401 600.00 S.F. S/W .38 228.00 37 . LOT 1 BLK 51 - —0— S.F. S/W .00 —0— m 36 BLUFF PORTION 73.30 S.F. D/W 1-1.0 3.51 257.28 b 33 *CR 7 LF RTN —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0- 3= 825.627, 3. u 33 N STAPLES STREET 77 36 END LAKE ST. +. 37 NORTH SIDE 51 36 6= as LAKE STREET 53 •+ N ALAMEDA TO N STAPLES 6. . SOUTH SIDE ," .3 37 44 58 . 33 ADOLPH GONZALES ** 146.00 L.F.C.G.& PVMT. 17.94 2,619.24 37 66 •• 4034 KILLARMET 78413 —0— L.F.C.G.& PVMT. —0— —0— ^+ 43 LOT 7 BLK 50 * —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— e; ,6 BLUFF PORTION —0- S.F. S/W —0— —0— .. .3 A-1 —0— S.F. D/W —0— —065 — m *CR EXST INPUTS —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— 8 **CR 4LF RTN 3: VACANT 2,619.24" 63 3a 7, 73 65 73 • ns 23 3 by DATA 0OCUMNTS/INC MAY 13. 1981 PAGE 11 ' ITEM 6 NO. OWNER AND PROPERTY DESCRIPTION DESCRIPTION QUANTITY OF ASSESSED ASSESSMENT RATE AMOUNT TOTAL ' AMOUNT ASSESSED • _ s 4 s ] e a ] 34 JUAN GONZALES ** 150.00 L.F.C.G.6 PVMT. 17.94 2,691.00 ; . 902 S BROWNLEE 78404 —0— L.F.C.G.0 PVMT. —0— —0— • LOT 6 BLK 50 * —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— BLUFF PORTION —0— S.F. S/W —0— —0— 13 A-1 —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0— 1< 16 1= *CR FYST IMPVT —0— S.F. D/W —0— —0-16 1° **CR 7LF RTN ] 1• VACANT 2,691.00. 16 21 '] NORTH STAPLES STREET 22 16 END LAKE ST :. '• SOUTH SIDE _' TO 26 2] 21 26 . END PROJECT 2. 2l 22 )1 32 2 33 26 4 1 35 2] 26 26 i] . TOTAL ASSESSMENTS *** 60,765.77 6 241 a+ 22 34 u 2es. 33 • ] 66 46 n w 36 sl 2• '-} 63 43 3] 41 51 59 42 66 d, ]] 33 4s 80 46 at ] 42 sl 46 s4 s w sl 66 2 69 2 ]6 4 ]1 n ss ]2 6 74 n 1 74 SECTION 4. Be it further ordained that in the event the actual frontage of any property herein assessed shall be found upon the completion of said improvements to be greater or less than the number of feet herein- above stated, the assessments herein set against any such property and against the real and true owner or owners thereof, shall be, and the same are hereby declared to be increased or decreased as the case may be, in the proportion which said excess or deficiency or frontage shall bear to the whole number of front feet of property actually improved in accordance with the front foot rule or rate of assessment herein adopted, it being the intention that such parcel of property and the real and true owner or owners thereof abutting on the portion of the streets above described, within the limits defined, shall pay for said improvements under the "FRONT FOOT RULE OR PLAN", which rule or plan is hereby found and determined to be just and equitable and -to produce a substantial equality, having in view the special benefits to be received and the burdens imposed thereby; and it is further ordained that upon final com- pletion and acceptance of said improvements on the aforesaid streets, within the limits defined all certificates hereinafter provided for, issued to evi- dence said assessments against said parcels of property abutting upon said street, and the real and true owner or owners thereof shall be issued in accordance with, and shall evidence the actual frontage of said property and the actual cost of said improvements, the amount named in said certificate in no case to exceed the amount herein assessed against such property unless such increase be caused by an excess of front footage over the amount hereinabove - stated, such actual cost and such actual number of front feet,iif4dffferent from the hereinabove shown in Section 3 hereof, to be determined by the Director of Engineering & Physical Development upon completion of said work or said street, and the findings of the Director of Engineering & Physical Development shall be final and binding upon all parties concerned. SECTION 5. That the several sums mentioned above in Section 3 hereof assessed against said parcels of property abutting on the aforesaid streets, within the limits defined, and the real and true owners thereof, whether named or correctly named herein or not, subject to the provisions of Section 4 thereof, together with interest thereon at the rate of six and one- half - (6. 1/2%) per annum with reasonable attorney's fee and all costs and -7- expenses of collection, if incurred, are hereby declared to be made a first and prior lien upon the respective parcels of property, against which same are assessed from and after the date said improvements were ordered by said City Council, to -wit: April 8, 1981 were a personal liability and charge against the real and true owner or ownerss be named or correctly named herein, and that said lien shall be.and contitute the first and prior enforceable claim against the property assessed and shall be a first and paramount lien superior to all other liens, claims or title, expect for lawful ad valorem taxes; and that the same so assessed shall be paid and become payable in one of the following methods at the option of the property owner: 1. All in cash within 30 days after completion or acceptance by City; or 2. Payments to be made in maximum of 60 equal installments, the first of which shall be paid within 30 days after the completion of said improvement, and the acceptance thereof by the City, and balance to be paid in 59 equal consecutive monthly installments commencing on the 1st day of the next succeeding month until the entire sum is paid in full, together with interest from the date of said completion and acceptance by the City, until paid, at the rate of six and one-half percent (6 1/2%) per annum; provided, however, that the owners of said property availing themselves of Option "2" or "3" above shall have the privilege of paying one, or all, of such installments at any time before maturity thereof by paying the total amount of principal due, together with interest accrued, to the date of payment. 3. The total number of monthly installments on owner occupied property may be extended beyond sixty (60) in number so that, at the owner's request, the tital monthly payments will not exceed ten ($10.00) per month. Section 6. That for the purpose of evidencing said assessments, the liens securing same and the several sums assessed against the said parcels -8- or property and the real and true owner or owners thereof and the time and terms or payment, and to aid in the enforcement thereof, assignable certif- icates shall be issued by the City of Corpus Christi, Texas to itself upon the completion of said improvements in said streets and acceptance thereof by said City Council, which certificates shall be executed by the Mayor in the name of the City, attested by the City Secretary, with the corporate seal of said City, and which certificates shall declare the amounts of said assessments and the times and terms thereof, the rate of interest thereon, the date of the completion and acceptance of the improvements for which the certificate is issued, and shall contain the names of the apparent true owner or owners as accurately as possible, and the description of the pro- perty assessed by lot and block number, or front foot thereof, or such other description as may otherwise identify the same,..and if the said pro- perty shall be owned by an estate or firm, then to so state the fact shall be sufficient and no error or mistake in describing such property or in giving the name of any owner or owners, or otherwise, shall in anywise invalidate or impair the assessment leived hereby or the certificate -issued in eividence thereof. That said certificate shall further provide substantially that if default shall be made in the payment of any installment of principal or interest when due, then at the option of the City, its successors, or assigns, or the holder thereof, the whole of said assessment evidence there- by shall at once become due and payable, and shall be collectible with reasonable attorney's fees and all expenses and costs of collection, if incurred, and said certificate shall set forth and evidence the personal liability of the real and true owner or owners of such property, and that Said lien is first and paramount thereon, superior to all other liens, titles and charges, except for lawful ad valorem taxes, from and after the date said improvements were ordered by said City Council, to -wit: April 8, 19 81 and shall provide in effect that if default shall be made in the payment thereof, the same may be enforced, at the option of the City, or their successors and assigns, by the sale of the property therein described in the manner provided for the collection of ad valorem taxes as above re- cited, or by suit in any Court having jurisdiction. -9- That said certificates shall further recite in effect that all the proceedings with reference to making said improvements have been regularly had in compliance with the law and Charter in force in said City and the proceedings of said City Council of said City, and that all prereq- uisites to the fixing of the assessment lien against the property therein described, or attempted to be described, and the personal liability of the real and true owner or owners thereof, evidence by such certificates, have been regularly done and performed, which recitals shall be evidence of all the matters and facts so recited and no further proof thereof shall be required in any Court. That said certificates shall further provide in effect that the City of Corpus Christi, Texas, shall exercise all of its lawful powers, in the enforcement and collection thereof, and said certificates may contain other and further recitals, pertinent and appropriate thereto. It shall not be necessary that said certificates shall be in the exact form as above set forth, but the substance and effect thereof shall suffice. SECTION 7. That all such assessments levied are a personal lia- bility and charge against the real and true owner or owners of the property described, or attempted to be described, notwithstanding such owner or owners may not be named or correctly named, and any irregularity in the name of the property owner, or the description of any property or the amount of any assessment, or in any other matter or thing shall not in anywise invalidate or impair any assessment levied hereby or any certificate issued, and such mistake, or error, invalidity or irregularity whether in such assessment or in the certificate issued in evidence thereof, may be, but is not required to be, to be enforceable, at any time corrected by the said City Council of •the City of Corpus Christi. Further that the omission of said improvements in front of any part of parcel of property abutting upon the aforementioned streets, which is exempt from the lien of said assessment, shall in no wise affect or impair the validity of assessments against the other parcels of property abutting upon said street; and that the total amounts assessed against the respective parcels of property abutting upon said streets with- in the limits herein defined and the real and true owner or owners thereof, are the same as, or less than, the estimate of said assesment prepared by -10- the Director of Engineering and Physical Development and approved and adopted by the City Council and are in accordance with the proceedings of said City Council relative to said improvements and assessments thereof, and with the terms, power and provisions of said Chapter 106 of the Acts of the First Called Session of the 40th Legislature of the State of Texas and Charter of the City of Corpus Christi, Texas, under which terms, powers and provisions said proceedings, said improvements and assessments were come hand and made by said City Council. SECTIO? 8. The fact that the above-described streets have be - important thoroughfares and the fact that the present condition of said streets, within the limits defined, are dangerous to the health and public welfare of the inhabitants thereof creates a public emergency and an imperative public necessity, requiring the suspension of the Charter rule that no ordinance or resolution shall be passed finally on the date of its introduction, and that said ordinance shall be read at three several meetings of the City Council, and the Mayor having declared that such emer- gency and necessity exists, and having requested that said Charter rule be suspended, and that this ordinance be passed finally on the date of its introduction and take effect and be in full force and effect from and after its passage, IT IS ACCORDINGLY SO ORDAINED, this the 13th day of May 1981 ATTEST: Secretary APPROVED: 13th DAY OF May J. BRUCE AYCOCK, CITY ATTORNEY By Assistan ity Attorney 19 81 : MAYOR THE C OF CORPUS CHRISTI, TEXAS Corpus Christi, Texas )3 day of , 192' TO THE MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL Corpus Christi, Texas For the reasons set forth in the emergency clause of the foregoing ordinance, a public emergency and imperative necessity exist for the suspension of the Charter rule or requirement that no ordinance or resolution shall be passed finally on the date it is introduced, but that such ordinance or resolution shall be read at three meetings of the City Council; I/we, therefore, request that you suspend said Charter rule or requirement and pass this ordinance finally on the date it is introduced, or at the present meeting of the City Council. •Respectfully, Council Members Respectfully, MAY Th-%. ty of Corpus Christi, Texas The Charter rule was suspended by the following vote: Luther Jones Betty N. Turner Jack K. Dumphy Bob Gulley Herbert L. Hawkins, Jr. Dr. Charles W. Kennedy Cliff Zarsky The above ordinance was passed by Luther Jones Betty N. Turner Jack K. Dumphy Bob Gulley Herbert L. Hawkins, Jr. Dr. Charles W. Kennedy Cliff Zarsky 16247 the following vote: 110 r